A locomotive parked across train tracks in Colton, California, blocked a competing railroad’s expansion northward in the summer of 1883. 

The Southern Pacific Railroad used freight cars, locomotives and armed guards to prevent construction. Among those guards was Virgil Earp, brother of famed lawman Wyatt Earp.

Virgil Earp is pictured here. Photo provided by David Mackesey.

The confrontation, known as the Frog War, ended Sept. 13, 1883. Backed by a legal ruling and the governor, California Southern Railroad workers installed a crossing that allowed trains to continue north toward San Bernardino. 

Historian David Mackesey will examine the dispute and its connection to Coronado’s development during the Coronado Historical Association’s Wine & Lecture Series on Thursday, Nov. 19. 

“Through sheer will and risk, they found a way to cross the Southern Pacific tracks to finally bring rail to San Diego in 1883,” Mackesey said.

Southern Pacific resisted efforts by the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway and its California Southern affiliate to establish a competing route. California Southern had been building north from National City but needed to cross Southern Pacific’s tracks at Colton to reach San Bernardino. 

A court ordered Southern Pacific to allow the crossing, which required installing a specially designed section of track called a “frog.” Southern Pacific continued blocking the site with railroad equipment. 

On Sept. 13, California Southern engineers arrived with the court order and local law enforcement. Earp ordered the blocking locomotive moved, and workers installed the crossing. California Southern’s Engine No. 4 then traveled across Southern Pacific’s tracks into San Bernardino. 

A historic photograph shows a railroad station in San Diego during the city’s early railroad era. Photo provided by David Mackesey.

Vickie Stone, curator of collections at the Coronado Historical Association, said expanding railroad connections helped fuel Southern California’s population growth and the real estate boom of the 1880s. 

“Without the connection of Southern California to the transcontinental railroad and its subsequent extensions, Coronado may never have developed as we know it today,” Stone said. 

An 1876 illustration shows San Diego and its waterfront seven years before the railroad confrontation known as the Frog War. Image provided by David Mackesey.

Stone said Mackesey has worked with the association for years and previously delivered lectures about Coronado’s golf history. He approached the organization with his new research into the Frog War. 

Mackesey’s interest in the confrontation began with curiosity about a house across the street from his home in Diablo, a Northern California community about 30 miles east of San Francisco. 

Built in 1876 by Southern Pacific executive David D. Colton, the house led Mackesey to research the railroad official while documenting the history of Diablo Country Club, which occupies land Colton once owned. The railroad town where the Frog War occurred was named after him. 

Southern Pacific Railroad executive David D. Colton was the namesake of Colton, California, where the 1883 Frog War took place. Image from History of the Southern Pacific by Stuart Daggett.

His research eventually led him to Coronado and Scottish golfer Alex Smith, whose career connected the island’s early resort industry with the golf club in Diablo. 

Hotel del Coronado opened in 1888, five years after the railroad confrontation. As expanding rail connections brought more visitors to Southern California, the hotel’s golf program became another draw. 

Coronado established an early golf course in the late 1890s, and Smith arrived in 1899. He spent seven winters helping develop the resort’s golf program and attracting visitors who wanted to watch and learn from accomplished players. Smith later won the U.S. Open in 1906 and 1910.

Mackesey said railroad executives used appearances by prominent golfers to promote rail travel and hotel stays. 

“When they announced that Alex Smith or his brother or their other golfing compatriots were going to be there for the season, they would sell railroad tickets and they would sell hotel rooms,” Mackesey said. 

Smith’s family later settled in Diablo, where several family members worked at the country club built on Colton’s former property. 

Mackesey said his research included historical records at Hotel del Coronado, the Coronado Historical Association and the San Diego History Center. Hotel records revealed Smith’s arrival dates and room assignments, while advertisements and contracts documented how the resort promoted visiting golf professionals. 

The Coronado Historical Association will host a wine-and-cheese reception at 5:30 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, followed by the lecture from 6 to 7 p.m. at 1100 Orange Ave.

Tickets cost $20 for members and $30 for nonmembers. Reservations are required. Tickets are available through the association’s website or by calling 619-435-7242. 

More News

Roman Aguilar is a general assignment reporter for The Coronado News. He holds a bachelor's degree in journalism from San Diego State University, where he served as sports editor of The Daily Aztec for three years. Originally from Stockton, California, Aguilar enjoys going to concerts, watching horror movies and visiting record stores in his free time. He can be reached at 209-608-6369.